Last time this was done regarding BYU back in basketball season, their fans lost their shit like this website has never seen before. But it can be fun to hear them whine (case and point), especially when a prediction comes about as close as you can come to totally nailing it.
Predicting football can be a little tougher though. There's a lot more positions that are tougher to have nailed down, injuries factor in quite a bit, and once-projected starters sometimes end up beat out for spots by this point in the season. But after five games each, there's enough out there to make a solid judgement about both teams.
On one hand, there's a team who is a chip-shot field goal away from being undefeated, with a trilling win over Utah mixed in with a few blowouts. On the other side is a 3-2 team who has pounded the weaklings they've played, but both above average teams have solidly outplayed them, even if the final scores didn't indicate it. And on both sides, you have very good defenses.
